DeepScar: Region-Traceable Deepfake Forensics via Secure Watermarking
Reviewer FhZY Con4
No comparison with other related works.
Reviewer tRk5 Con3
The adding salt process is overly simplistic.
Reviewer tRk5 Q1
Can you elaborate on its effectiveness against full-image or non-face deepfake?
Reviewer tRk5 Q3
providing a theoretical proof as to how the key ensures security
Reviewer tRk5 Q4
Can the localization shown in Figure 5 be elaborated upon regarding its accuracy?
Reviewer HN1c Con3
No deepfake detection methods compared.
Reviewer Lomu Q3
No deepfake-related watermarking methods compared.
Reviewer Lomu Q5
There needs to be more information about what happens if this model takes the vanilla image that is not manipulated by the deepfake technique and does not have a watermark as input.
Reviewer Lomu Q8
There is no explanation of the differences between the combinations of deepfake algorithms (e.g., SimSwap, FaceSwap) and datasets (e.g., FF++, Celeb-DF).
Reviewer Lomu Q9
there is no information on why the other combinations are omitted (e.g., SimSwap with DFDC).
